Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: How Not To Criticize Tom Brady For The Patriots' Loss

Gary Andersen is gone. Who should replace him?

It's official, Gary Andersen will be named the head coach of the Utah State Aggies tomorrow at one. I wish him the best of luck in Logan and hope Whittingham can find a solid replacement for not only Andersen's coaching, but his strong in-state recruiting, as well.

It's a huge loss, but one I think most of us expected. I also trust Whittingham and believe he will bring in the most capable coach to lead Utah's defense in the coming years. But since we don't have an idea of who is likely to get the job, all we can do is speculate. And that is exactly what I want us to do. 

Who do you think should replace Andersen as Utah's defensive coordinator? 

Some names I'll throw around: 

Steve Kaufusi: Currently the defensive line coach at, gulp, BYU, Kaufusi's name has been tossed around by a few locally. While he played at Brigham Young, he was also a graduate assistant for the Utes in 1994, the defensive line coach from 1995 to 1996 and from 1997 to 2001, coached the defensive ends. The biggest drawback, in my mind, is that BYU's d-line hasn't been all that spectacular. He does know the program, though and obviously has some strong ties to the state.

Aaron Alford: Currently the cornerbacks coach here at Utah, arrived in 2007. Prior to that, coached defensive backs at Akron, Wyoming, Western Illinois and Southern Utah. Alford is probably my favorite, because I think he's done a bang up job with the cornerbacks here since arriving in 2007. Though he isn't as deeply rooted within the state as Kaufusi, he's been here for two seasons and knows the program, especially its current state. 

Kalani Sitake: Has been coaching at Utah since Kyle Whittingham took over in 2005. Currently the inside linebackers coach and prior to that, coached the offensive line, tight ends and running backs at Southern Utah. Graduated from BYU and worked as a graduate assistant for the Cougars during the 2002 season. Like Kaufusi, he has deep ties with not only the Ute program, but the state as a whole. He did play fullback for BYU, but we can't hold that against him, right? 

Rocky Long: Former head coach of New Mexico, Long has said he would be open to being a defensive coordinator for another program. This would be a very high-profile hire, but seems pretty unlikely. Long would be a solid coach, but admits to not being a good recruiter and that is something Utah needs right now. 

Morgan Scalley: Not going to happen, but I'll still mention him. He's a great Ute, loves the school and I could see him being Utah's defensive coordinator down the line. If the Utes weren't at the level they currently are, they could probably get away with this type of hire. But it's a risky one and for a program of this magnitude, it's probably not worth it.

That's my list for now. I'll put them in a poll, but if you have any suggestions, let me know! 

Poll
Who do you want as Utah's next defensive coordinator?
Steve Kaufusi
18 votes
Aaron Alford
25 votes
Kalani Sitake
35 votes
Rocky Long
34 votes
Morgan Scalley
8 votes
Other (please post)
6 votes

126 votes | Poll has closed

Comment 8 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

sitake or kaufusi

Woodraska at the SLTrib speculates that Sitake could go with Anderson as USU’s defensive coordinator. I guess they are pals.

The nature of successful recruiting for this team dictates that there always be at least one Polynesian coach (probably should be LDS too) on the staff. If Sitake leaves, we will need a Polynesian coach somewhere on the defense. It doesn’t necessarily have to be Kaufusi or the defensive coordinator, but it’s something to keep in mind.

What’s Luther Ellis up to these days? Would he like to coach a defensive line someday?

by sancho on Dec 4, 2008 9:20 AM MST reply actions  

I'd like an outside guy.

Maybe Sitake or Kaufusi, especially considering that might heal some wounds with the Kaufusi family, but I don’t know if either of them are ready to be DC. I think Kyle should take a good look at coordinators whose HCs recently lost their job.

Everyone hates a pink-shirt-wearing communist.

by displacedute on Dec 4, 2008 12:57 PM MST reply actions  

I'd like Rocky Long

I think that would be huge for the Utes to get Long as the DC. Although, I think it would be interesting to see what Scalley could do. I guarantee he will be at that point sometime. Just not right now. I like the idea of Long tho. I think that he has always had one of the best defenses (especially against Utah for some reason) at New Mexico. Really, I just hope we get a qualified guy, that knows what to do. Quite unlike Ludwig…

GO UTES!!

by Jman87 on Dec 4, 2008 5:17 PM MST reply actions  

Long and Ludwig

I don’t think I want Long. Chemistry is important, and I don’t think being DC under a coach in the same league where you used to be a HC is a good idea.

As for Ludwig, I have bashed the guy nonstop for 3 years, but if you have any complaints about our offense this year, you’re crazy.

Everyone hates a pink-shirt-wearing communist.

by displacedute on Dec 4, 2008 6:37 PM MST up reply actions  

One reason for long

You go with the best whenever you can and recruting means nada if the guys don’t play up to their potential (see Weis, C., T. Bowden, T. Bowden, P. Fulmer, and R. Zook. 2008. Why recruiting is meaningless if you motivate like a cold turd. Sports Psych, 18(6):124-143.). Meyer changed the team by making them play every down with every ounce they had—Rocky Long does same.

You win games, your recruting goes up so he’d cover his own butt that way.

Take the best, go for Long though doing anything you can to keep Kaufusi seems smart to me—need Polynesian coaches.

by Aardvark on Dec 5, 2008 7:04 AM MST reply actions  

Bigger problems...

There was an interesting question brought up in a recent post that could cause bigger problems. Not only who will take Anderson’s place and keep the defense nationally ranked, but who might Anderson take with him? At Utah State there will be coaching vacancies to fill and who’s to say that some of the current Ute coaches won’t fill them.

Instead of filling one vacancy, there may be multiple ones to fill.

by Keola10 on Dec 5, 2008 10:05 AM MST reply actions  

Not always a problem . . .

With Utah’s spotlight in the national sports press it might be an opportunity to bring in some quality peeps. Let’s hope that is the case. Next year looms as a rebuilding project on offense anyway.

by Aardvark on Dec 5, 2008 11:41 AM MST up reply actions  

Some concern, but I think we'll ok in that department.

Aaron Roderick is probably the most likely coach to leave with Andersen and maybe Kalani Sitake. Sitake might want the Utah DC position, but from what I’m hearing, Whittingham might not think he’s ready.

Losing Roderick would hurt, but all these coaches are replaceable. And as MeanBobMean said, with the program being at the high profile it currently is, getting other coaches to come here won’t be too difficult.

I mean, Aaron Alford came from outside the program and he’s been one of Utah’s most successful coaches.

by JazzyUte on Dec 5, 2008 12:17 PM MST up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

"I can't think of many schools that are better than Utah."
- Urban Meyer


"Wow. Wow. Wow."
- Daryl Johnston after Utah took a 21-0 lead on Alabama in the 2009 Sugar Bowl

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Ut_small
Pac 12 prohibits neutral site games
Small
Travis Wilson vs. Chase Hansen
Small
Good place for Info?
Bigpapi1_small
A pro-style/spread hybrid and other random musings....
Small
Who has you excited?
Logo_small
Basketball MUSS
Glacier_07_161_small
Foster coming back for a season!!
Logo_small
Storey thrown under the bus?
Small
My experience in Happy Valley
Small
Greg Allen stiffs Utah, Commits to Kansas

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >