CSU report card
Though it was far from perfect, I think the way Utah bounced back from their 14-point deficit makes this one of the best Ute games in recent years. I'm not sure when the last time Utah climbed back from a two-touchdown hole and actually won (maybe someone knows or can find out). Regardless, it was a huge win that gave this team the confidence I think they lacked during the 2005 rebuilding campaign. If anything, this season looks exactly the opposite of that one (Utah often led in many of those games they lost, blowing second-half leads multiple times).
Not this time, though - or so I hope.
Offense: B - They only really played poorly in the second quarter. The offense did have that inexcusable turnover at the start of the third, but beyond that, they were pretty consistent. I think when Shaky Smithson went out, it threw the coaches in a panic and they pulled away from Eddie Wide fearing a similar injury. Had Wide gone down, it's probably one of the most disastrous losses in recent history.
Now I don't know if that was their plan throughout the day (not giving Wide touches) or designed that way just for the second quarter, but it almost cost them. Regardless, the coaches wised up, played Wide and what do you know, the Utes' offense pretty much rolled.
One major reason for that success in the second half, however, comes down to Terrance Cain. He was amazing. Probably one of the best performances for a first-year quarterback in recent Utah history. I mean, he didn't make the mental mistakes that Grant Stucker did for the Rams and pretty much kept the offense pushing down the field in crunch time. A fantastic showing and hopefully this will be his coming out party.
Defense: B - I don't think the defense was overpowered by the Rams as much as some might indicate. Utah's defense only started stumbling when the offense had quick three and outs and turned the ball over. Which isn't a surprise, because when you're on the field for so long, you start getting gassed. Once the offense built some momentum, the defense stepped it up (well Robert Johnson, anyway) and preserved the Ute victory.
Though Colorado State has issues on the offensive end, I do believe they will be one of the best offenses Utah faces this season. So the fact they held them to 17-points, in their house, isn't entirely a bad thing.
Special Teams: B - Another B. I wasn't too disappointed with the special teams. I think the Utes returned punts and kickoffs well and pretty much kept the Rams' return team in check for most of the game. No missed field goals and extra points helps here.
Coaches:
- Dave Schramm: C-plus - I want to give him a B, but I don't know if I should. Mostly because I'm not clear if holding out Wide was a precaution or just a momentary lapse on his part. I will concede he stepped it up in the second half and pretty much called the needed plays to put Utah in scoring position.
- Kalani Sitake: B - I went over how the defense looked gassed in that second and early third quarter and I think that really had more to do with the offense than anything else. Once things started going well for the offense, the defense responded and kept the Rams scoreless on three consecutive drives at the end of the game.
- Kyle Whittingham: B-plus - With the team down 14, this game was getting out of control fast. It's the head coaches responsibility to rally the troops in such a scenario and Whittingham did just that. The fact it came on the road against a fairly decent opponent makes it all the more impressive.
0 recs |
13 comments
|
Comments
I think I have seen it more often go the other way.
Especially in the McBride days, losing a 14+ point lead in the fourth was not unheard of.
by utesfan100 on Oct 13, 2009 8:51 AM MDT reply actions 0 recs
I think you're right...
It’s good to know we really have fully exorcised those McBride demons.
Especially Whittingham. This guy had it tough. He had to replace the greatest coach in Utah football history and at first looked a bit more like McBride than he did Meyer.
But slowly he chipped away at that perception.
2008 was bigger for the program than 2004 because it proved Whittingham had the goods. 2004 very well could have just been a flash in the pan created by the Urban Meyer Gang.
Now the more we win, the more vindication Whittingham is getting that 2008 was more than just luck.
If Utah goes 11-2 or 12-1, it will mean we’ve created a monster that will dominate at this level like Boise State has the WAC. And we’ll do it in a much better conference.
by JazzyUte on Oct 13, 2009 2:35 PM MDT up reply actions 0 recs
Eddie Wide
Plays his heart out and I don’t understand why folks don’t give him more credit. The only thing he lacks is size (comes in handy when he has to block big D-Ends), otherwise I am a big fan and think he opens up the options for Utah on offense. What’s up with Shak and why is there no mention of Ray Stowers?
The first time Shak runs the ball against a weak San Jose St. team and he’s out 4 weeks? Not sure I feel comfortable with him backing up Wide at this point. Any idea if he’ll be back next week? Is Ray Stowers just not good enough to play? If nothing else, he’s 6-2 and 222lbs…
by Ute Fan in San Fran on Oct 13, 2009 10:16 AM MDT reply actions 0 recs
only game utah is going to lose is to tcu. 10-2 is very good year.
when they beat the fifth place pac-ten team in the vegas bowl that will make nine straight bowl wins and a 11-2 record. very good considering the injury problems. t. cain will be much better next year and i hope the ncaa will give matt a. another year of eligibility. utah has gotten a couple of breaks before. it’s not unheard of to get two medical redshirts but it definitely could be denied.
by wolfmanshowlforever on Oct 13, 2009 12:18 PM MDT reply actions 0 recs
According to the U media guide
The last time Utah overcame a 14 point deficit to win was 2004. Utah trailed AFA 0–14 and won 45–31. That probably isn’t the best example because Utah fell behind so quickly and the offense was so explosive that pretty much everyone knew Utah would make a comeback. (Everyone, that is, except Jazzy, who is a pessimist come game time.)
Before that is 1995—also against AFA. Utah trailed 7–21 with about a minute to play in the game. Mike Fouts connected with Rocky Henry for a 17-yard touchdown reception. Chris Fuamatu-Ma’afala scored the two-point conversion on the old “Duck” play.
Utah recovered the onside kick when the ball bounced of the chest of Nakia Addison for the Falcons. Utah scored a touchdown on the next play when Fouts connect to Kevin Dyson for the win.
Deseret News article about the game.
by Ute in DC on Oct 13, 2009 4:37 PM MDT reply actions 0 recs
Thanks!
I actually can’t believe I forgot about that AFA game. I was there. I remember falling down 14-0 and thinking, “well there goes the BCS bid…”
haha, so you’re right. I was freaking. I think I thought this as I waited in line to get a hotdog and the Falcons had just scored…:/
So basically, the last one that really counts was a miracle comeback that happened through a fluke onside kick.
Yeah…fitting that type of play would come under McBride.
by JazzyUte on Oct 13, 2009 4:53 PM MDT up reply actions 0 recs
Now what about on the road?
I bet you’d have to even further back than 1995 for that one…
by JazzyUte on Oct 13, 2009 4:55 PM MDT up reply actions 0 recs
1991 at Wyoming
I don’t remember this game at all, but Utah trailed 14–29 in the first half and also 22–36 in the third quarter. They won 57–42.
by Ute in DC on Oct 13, 2009 5:05 PM MDT up reply actions 0 recs
That takes me back...
For the record the BCS started in 1998, and Utah could not earn a spot in the Bowl Alliance that year.
That was my first season as a Utah fan. I happened to also knew Mike Fouts off the field. Excellent person, good QB.
For some reason I remembered this game for the scoring of three TD’s in the final two minutes, but my memory had the game as a loss. I am glad to correct that memory.
I remember walking out of the stadium after the game through the old exits to the East to the south end zone. This part of the stadium was then a chain linked fence with a service road where the Air Force buses were parked. I remember the service men returning to the buses.
I also remember the Stanford game that year. I was a transfer student from Florida who didn’t know about student sections. I was told pretty much just show up and sit wherever you wanted, so I sat near the 50 yard line about 3/4 of the way up the east stands without issue. I have heard times have changed.
Coming from the heart of SEC and ACC country, and being mostly an NFL fan at the time, I expected to see a mockery of a football team. “Utah? pffft. No real football here.”
I remember sitting in the stands that day watching the game impressed by the talent on the field and thinking this team is competitive. I remember some horrible play calling, and an inability to stick with the plays that were working well. Utah should have won that day. I also remember trying what any SEC or ACC fan at the time would do and express this to the fans around me. The McBride cult was alive and well, so I bit my tongue.
I attended every home game from then until the Wyoming game in 2001 when I returned to Florida. I would not see another Utah game live until January 2009. I remember yelling alone on third and critical on several occasions. I almost wrote a letter to the crony on several occasions to outline proper cheering to establish a true home field advantage.
Only after Meyer’s success and learning about where Utah was before McBride did I eventually come to appreciate what he had done for the team.
By the time I left Utah in the fall of 2001 I had become a Utah man, and I will be till I die.
by utesfan100 on Oct 13, 2009 10:29 PM MDT up reply actions 0 recs
Great story...
Things have changed so much since even 2002.
I remember the UNLV game in 2002. It was cold and the Utes sucked, so no one showed. You could probably park a hummer in the student section without hitting one fan.
I think that was the game that ultimately did McBride in. I mean, he was hanging on by a threat anyway but to have so few fans there sealed everything.
by JazzyUte on Oct 13, 2009 11:16 PM MDT up reply actions 0 recs
Anyone notice
All of our RB’s are getting injured after long runs. Shak goes down with a injury after a 46 yard TD run. Asiata goes out with a injury after a 24 yard TD, than last game Shaky gets injured after a 22 yard run. What the heck is going on. Well i’d rather it be a long run than after a 5 yard loss or a fumble or something…Hope we can get these guys healthy, Wide established himself as our go to back but it would be nice to have different options available.
by utahmanami on Oct 13, 2009 9:44 PM MDT reply actions 0 recs
utah has been a lucky team in the past without getting many injuries
we have to do what every other team does, suck it up. eddie wide is a decent back. we will have to rely on our wr’s and te’s more. i would like more slants in the utah gameplan. not only does it work but it’s my favorite play in college football.
by wolfmanshowlforever on Oct 14, 2009 1:25 PM MDT up reply actions 0 recs

by 









